On another post, Bryn had brought up the Aetherial Shield, claiming it was useless. I disagree, but I didn't want to hi-jack the other post. So I started this one.
The Aetherial Shield will, when bashing, turn an enemy ethereal. The enemy is unable to harm anyone, nor be harmed. The enemy will also flee. The effects last 15 seconds (this time from its description is incorrect - the actual time is about half). I believe the shield works on every type of enemy but dragons.
So how can this be useful to the player? Here is basically what I have so far:
Honestly, in most cases, I would prefer the Aetherial Crown, but the shield works for certain situations and characters. I haven't tried it, but I wonder if it works if you 'bash' an ally - if so, there's some added uses (such as having an ally avoid a trap).
So what do you guys think? Can you think of other ways the shield can be put to use?
Update: After this post and other conversations on the blog, I find the Aetherial Shield to be very powerful.
Shield has it's uses. Henson showed how it can be used offensively in his Forgotten. Sure, it does not support traditional bash+hack playstyle, but can be used in other ways. For example, bash with Disarming Bash and while enemy flees calmly collect his weapon leaving him unarmed...
But you might use it against a troll when you are fighting two. Each time he returns, bash him again - until the other one is dead. Who cares if they regenerate if they're not wounded in the first place.
Anytime you use it for crowd control, use it on the unwounded enemies. Attack the wounded ones - bash the unwounded.
The more ideas I see here, the more it makes me want to grab that shield on my next play-through. I only need to decide whether I will use some variation of Henson's build, or come up with something totally different. It would take a 'clever' character though, not some mindless hack and slash guy. I think I'll wait a bit and see what more people come up with here.
(Another idea: I can also see it working for a non-combatant thief in emergency situations)
I added a lot of pomp and frills to my Forgotten build. If you break it down to an:
Aetherial Shield + Some sort of ranged attack, it is so much fun. You can even turn the Ebony Warrior ethereal and make him run LOL. As with my build, I suggest a crossbow because on their return trip, nothing is more satisfying then having that staggering bolt power.
The ethereal effect only lasts a few seconds (not 15 as advertised), it really doesn't prolong battle at all.
I agree with your comment in some ways Bryn, but you do play on lower game difficulties. On higher difficulties battles can last alot longer anyway and the A Shield can help you curse that two handed bandit chief briefy while you kill his two cronies...
...when he returns you can take him down one on one.
Overall using that item gives you a nice fresh mechanic to use during the monotony of general close combat.